Tips on food selection, purchasing, preparation and storage.
Resources related to food safety.
Resources related to food security, local food systems, and interventions that mediate or reduce food insecurity and hunger.
Nutrition and health information for all ages.
dietary supplement graphic

Can you benefit from taking a dietary supplement?

There are some select groups that are more likely to use and benefit from using dietary supplements. If you fall into one of the following groups of individuals you may want to consider taking a supplement: (create an anchor for each of the following)

 

Why might athletes take dietary supplements?

athlete

Athletes with less than optimal nutritional status compromise their physical performance. Athletes face several barriers to good nutrition--lack of nutrition knowledge, dietary extremism, poor practical skills in choosing or preparing meals, a busy lifestyle, and frequent travel. Nutrition plays a very important part in athletic performance, yet many active people fail to consume a diet that helps them perform at their optimum level. The first and most important modification an athlete must make to his or her diet to ensure optimal performance is to increase the energy intake in proportion to the energy used. Athletes also require more water, protein, vitamins and minerals (especially iron and calcium). To fulfill the extra nutritional requirements, athletes may turn to dietary supplements such as vitamin, mineral, protein and carbohydrate supplements. Before you stock up on these expensive dietary aids however, remember that it is cheaper and easier to just eat more food.

Ergogenic Aids

A substance used by an athlete to improve performance is called an ergogenic aid. Athletes have used ergogenic aids since ancient times. Ancient Greek Olympians ate mushrooms to increase their chances to win the laurel wreath and Aztec athletes ate human hearts. Nowadays the ergogenic aid industry is massive, and almost all sporting magazines contain advertisements for new "revolutionary" ergogenic aids. The world of sports is a competitive business. Athletes fear that others are taking something that will give them an advantage. This means that many athletes will try out new substances on the off chance that it will give them the edge over other competitors. Forgotten in the push to excel are the unknown dangers of unproven substances and the temptations for misuse and abuse. Supplements can be harmful as well as useful.

Supplements that may used by athletes as an ergogenic include: 

Ergogenic Aid

Proposed action

What research says

Side effects

Androstenedione

steroid hormone that increases testosterone levels

no documented benefits

major

Caffeine

increases fat metabolism, thus sparing glucose and glycogen stores; stimulates the central nervous system

supports

mild

Carbohydrates

an important energy source for muscles

supports

mild at high doses

Creatine

delays fatigue and improves performance during high, intense bursts of exercise; builds muscle mass

supports, however there is limited data on long-term use

mild

DHEA

increases amount of steroids produced in the body

no benefit in health athletes

may be dangerous

HMB

prevents muscle breakdown, speeds up muscle repair, and increase lean body mass

limited; some strength benefits

none

Protein

helps build muscle and improves muscle repair

supports; high force outputs from their muscles, such as sprinters and weight lifters, need extra protein to ensure muscle maintenance

none

Pycnogenol

boosts antioxidant levels, enhances recovery

Supports, dietary sources offer same benefit

none

Tryptophan

increases athletic endurance; decreases pain perception

no definite results; no benefit in trained athletes

potentially dangerous

Vitamin B6 (Pyridoxine)

increases growth of muscle and decreases anxiety

no benefit unless individual has deficiency

mild at high doses

Vitamin B12 (Cobalamin)

increases growth of muscle

no benefit unless individual has deficiency

none

Vitamin C

acts as an antioxidant; increases energy production and aerobic reactions

no benefit unless individual has deficiency

mild at high doses

Vitamin E

acts as an antioxidant; increases aerobic capacity

no definite results

mild

Zinc

increases muscle mass and aerobic capacity

few studies; mostly negative

mild

Source: Ahrendt DM. Ergogenic aids: Counseling the athlete. American Family Physician. 2001;63:913-22.

For more information on ergogenic aids, go to American Family Physician.

Caution!
Because of the lack of regulation with dietary supplements, athletes run the risk of consuming a dietary supplement that is contaminated. Ephedra (ephedrine) is one such contaminant that can be found in a number of dietary supplements. In addition, steroid contamination, such as anandrolone and testosterone, have been documented. An athlete WILL test positive for drug use if they consume a dietary supplement containing ephedra or steroids such as anandrolone and testosterone. Visit the Gatorade Sport Science Institute for more information.

Antioxidants

Exercise can have two detrimental effects on the body. First, the increased oxygen use by working muscles increases the amount of reactive forms of oxygen known as free-radicals. A growing amount of evidence indicates that free radicals cause skeletal muscle damage and inflammation during exercise [1]. People who exercise frequently and intensely should ensure that their consumption of antioxidants is sufficient to reduce recovery time[2]. This may be done with generous servings of fruits and vegetables or with dietary supplements. To prevent cell damage from free-radicals, antioxidants act by "mopping" them up. The traditional dietary antioxidants that inhibit free-radical damage are:

Vitamin E, Alpha tocopherol or tocopherol
Vitamin C or ascorbic acid
Vitamin A, Beta carotene or carotenoids

1. Sjödin B; Hellsten Westing Y; Apple FS: Biochemical mechanisms for oxygen free radical formation during exercise. Sports Med, 1990 Oct, 10:4, 236-54.

2. Goldfarb AH: Nutritional antioxidants as therapeutic and preventive modalities in exercise-induced muscle damage. Can J Appl Physiol, 1999 Jun, 24:3, 249-66.

stepping on a scaleSupplements for those wishing to lose weight

The thought of taking a pill to lose weight will never fail to attract interest. Many supplement manufacturing companies sell products that claim to be able to do this by "stimulating metabolism" or "blocking fat digestion." A review of the scientific studies turns up no solid evidence for the long term effectiveness of these products.

Two over-the-counter dietary supplements that are promoted to accelerate metabolism with subsequent weight loss have been labeled dangerous by the FDA. These two products are Ephedra (also known as Ma Huang, Ephedra sinica or Chinese ephedra), and Phenylpropanolamine.

In addition, other commonly used weight loss supplements like Cola acuminata, dwarf elder, Yohimbine, and Garcinia camborgia are either lacking controlled clinical trials, or in the case of the last two supplements, were shown in clinical trials to be ineffective (Garcinia was successful in trials as part of a mixture with other substances. It is unclear, however, if Garcinia itself was effective). The FDA also states that the safety of these weight loss supplements is currently unknown. With the increased marketing and use of these products, FDA has received an increasing number of reports of adverse reactions associated with their use including:

* Nervousness
* Dizziness
* Tremors
* Alterations in blood pressure or heart rate
* Headache
* Gastrointestinal distress
* Chest pain
* Myocardial infarction (heart attack)
* Hepatitis
* Stroke
* Seizures
* Psychosis
* Death

These adverse reactions have been reported both in young, healthy individuals and persons with confounding or complicating conditions such as high blood pressure. In addition, a stimulant "overdose" syndrome has been reported in children and teenagers who have used these products.

Related weight-loss products often marketed as "dieters" or "slimming teas" contain a variety of strong botanical laxatives and diuretics such as Cassia species (senna) and Cascara sagada. Adverse reactions associated with these products that have been reported to FDA are typically characteristic of those seen in laxative abuse. These include severe electrolyte imbalances leading to heart problems and even death.

The FDA is concerned about the seriousness of these reported adverse events and their increasing number. Because these weight loss products are commonly marketed as dietary supplements, there is no pre-market review by FDA of their safety or effectiveness, no reliable dosing information, and no monitoring advice.

Older Adults (65+)

older adultOlder adults (65+) are at an increased risk for poor nutrition.

  • With age, there is a reduction in lean body mass which reduces the body's energy requirements.

  • Older adults eat less total food.

  • Appetite may be decreased due to reduced taste and smell sensitivity.

  • Drug side effects can reduce appetite and reduce absorption and metabolism of vitamins and minerals.

  • Some nutrient requirements increase with age, especially calcium, vitamin E, vitamin D, riboflavins, folate, vitamin B12 and protein.

Undernutrition in older adults can lead to loss of muscle protein and deficiencies of vitamins B-6, B-12, D and E as well as calcium, folate and magnesium. These nutritional inadequacies can lead to the following:

Recommendations for the older adult

An adequate and balanced diet is without a doubt the best way to ensure adequate nutrition. However, much scientific evidence suggests that complementing the diet with a daily multivitamin-and-mineral supplement is a sensible precaution to help avoid nutrient deficiencies that are common in older adults.

Choose a supplement with very little or no iron. Iron needs of older adults are low, and excess iron increases the risk of developing cancer and heart disease.

In addition, look for a supplement that has no more than 100% of the RDA or DRI for vitamin A. With age, vitamin A is absorbed and retained more efficiently. The potential for vitamin A toxicity is therefore greater than at a younger age. Vitamin A toxicity is a serious matter, leading to such health problems as headache, vomiting, bone abnormalities, and liver damage.

Choose a dietary supplement that DOES NOT contain:

  • More than 100% RDA for iron

  • More than 100% RDA for vitamin A

Many vitamin and mineral supplements are aimed at the older adult. Read the labels and decide with the above warnings in mind.

If you are thinking about taking single nutrient supplements, only calcium and vitamin D have been specifically recommended for older adults. If you have any doubt whatsoever, visit your physician and get an individualized dietary assessment before taking supplements.

If you are currently taking any medication, be sure to discuss with your physician what supplements you can take. Many drugs interact with dietary supplements. Some supplements can prevent drugs from working. Other supplements can intensify drug effects to dangerous levels. Your physician and pharmacist will be able to provide more information.

Pregnant or planning on getting pregnant

pregnant woman eatingPregnant women must consider both their own requirements and the requirements of the baby. Vitamins and minerals are needed during pregnancy for the maintenance of the mother's health, to support the developing infant's growth, and to help prevent developmental defects.

Supplements to Consider:

 

Recommendations for Pregnancy

During pregnancy, some women can especially benefit from certain nutrients. In general, these would all be contained in a prenatal multivitamin/mineral supplement.  Those requiring vitamin and mineral supplementation in addition to a prenatal supplement include:

Supplementing additional nutrients other than iron and a prenatal multivitamin/mineral tablet is not only unnecessary, but can be dangerous. For example, taking mega doses of vitamin A may cause birth defects. Daily vitamin A intake in the range of 10,000 IU or more can result in defects of the fetal skeletal, urinary tract, and central nervous systems. Before taking any supplements, seek advice from your physician or a registered dietitian.

1. Czeizel AE; Dudás I: Prevention of the first occurrence of neural-tube defects by periconceptional vitamin supplementation. N Engl J Med, 1992 Dec, 327:26, 1832-5.

2. Vogt C: Iron requirements of pregnancy. Clin Issu Perinat Womens Health Nurs, 1991, 2:3, 364-7.

3. Repke JT, Villar J. Pregnancy-induced hypertension oand low birth weight: the role of calcium. Am J Clin Nutr 1991; 54(1 Suppl):237S-241S.

4. Menard MK: Vitamin and mineral supplement prior to and during pregnancy. Obstet Gynecol Clin North Am, 1997 Sep, 24:3, 479-98.

 

Vegetarians

Any restriction in the foods one would eat holds the potential for dietary inadequacies. It is through eating a wide variety of foods that we are assured of getting the wide range of nutrients humans need for good health. Dietary studies have often found that vegetarians, especially vegans, consume some vitamins and minerals at less than recommended amounts. A well-chosen vegetarian diet, on the other hand, can be entirely adequate, obviating the need for dietary supplements.

Although lacto-ovo-vegetarians have no obvious need for dietary supplements, vegans are a different story. At least one study has concluded that vegans need to increase their intake of vitamin B12, riboflavin and possibly even iodine, iron and zinc [1].

1. Reddy S, Saunders TB. Haematological studies on pre-menopausal Indian and Caucasian vegetarians compared with Caucasian omnivores. Brit J Nutrition 1990; 64: 331-338