H2S Control for Liquid Manure Storage Practices - Permeable
Covers
| Pro |
Con |
| Cost efficient for benefits gained |
Replacement over time (annually in some cases) |
| Variety of options available |
Biocovers may have removal issues |
Permeable covers, or biocovers act as biofilters
on the top of manure storage areas. Materials often used as covers
include straws, cornstalks, peat moss, foam, geotextile fabric,
and Leka™ rock. Permeable biocovers reduce emissions, in part,
by reducing both the radiation onto the manure storage surface and
the wind velocity over the surface of the storage area. Covers act
as a barrier to these forces. At the solution/air interface, humidity
is relatively high, which creates a stabilized boundary that slows
the emission rate of odorous volatiles. The aerobic zone within
the biocover allows the growth of aerobic microorganisms that utilize
carbon, nitrogen, and sulfur for growth. This aerobic zone should
also curtail the formation of reduced sulfur compounds, such as
hydrogen sulfide. Reported reductions in hydrogen sulfide emissions
have not been found; however, reports of odor reductions of 40 to
50 percent are common when various straw materials are used. An
odor reduction efficiency of 85 percent has been noted following
the use of a floating mat or corrugated materials.
Costs for biocovers vary widely depending on the
material used and the method of application. In Minnesota, an operation
employed a 1/8-inch thick geotextile material that cost $0.25 per
square foot, plus installation. Straw was added on top of the geotextile
cover for additional emission control. Straws and cornstalks cost
approximately $0.10 per square foot, applied annually; peat moss
and foam cost about $0.26 per square foot, applied annually; and
Leka™ rock costs in excess of $2.50 per square foot for a
3-inch layer, but only has to be applied one time. Leka™ rock
is a product of Norway, thereby requiring considerable shipping
costs ($5 to $6 per cubic foot). The cost to cover a 1.5-acre earthen
storage was $6,000 whereas an above ground tank with 0.2 acre was
$500, for the same material.
Cover
depth is very important for permeable covers. Most recommendations
suggest a minimum of 8-inch depth, preferably 10 to12-inch depth
of coverage on a manure storage surface. Leka™ rock needs
to be at least 3 to 4-inch deep. New covers (except Leka™
rock) need to be applied at least annually, and one study showed
that only 50 percent of the straw cover remained four months after
installation. Therefore management and re-investment costs need
to be considered. Removal of large, fibrous material during storage
cleanout must also be considered before selecting this option.
Extension Publications
Abstracts, Conference Proceedings, Presentations and Reports
Journal Articles
Newsletter Articles
Other Links
|